Thursday, September 21, 2017

Battle of Moisturiser: Hada Labo, Ginvera, Cerave, Cosmoderm, Imju Naturie

Assalamualaikum and hi,

'Not everyone need a moisturiser but everyone need nutrient' that's what Paula Begoun says. I have to agree with her phrase. I realize I don't need to go heavy on moisturiser because I am living in high humidity area but I do need humectant and antioxidant. So, I used a few moisturisers to provide nutrients for my skin, even though I know my skin is not going to eat all up. Hey, not all nutrients can penetrate deeper inside the skin. At least I try.

Moisturiser I currently/have use:

Imju Naturie Hatomugi Conditioning Gel, Hada Labo ACE Cream, Ginvera Marvel White Facial Lotion, Hada Labo Hydrating Milk, Cerave Moisturising Cream, Cosmoderm Vitamin 1000 IU Cream

Hada Labo Hydrating A.C.E Cream

Hada Labo ACE Cream ingredient list

HL ACE cream basically a moisturising cream with vitamin A (Retinyl Palmitate), C (Ascorbyl Palmitate) dan E (Tocopheryl Acetate) as antioxidant. I bought this because of the antioxidants. This cream has yellow tiny beads which contain vitamin A, C and E. It also contain squalane which is good for moisture barrier. The texture is quite light but I don't think oily skin can handle this cream.

My verdict: Firstly, I used this cream both day and night for about 3 months. My skin become oilier until I swiped with micellar water for wudhu' or reapplying sunscreen. After that, I just used this at night as a normal moisturiser. My face became brighter after I woke up. But for temporary. The cons is that there a bit little sting in a couple of minutes after I applied. This cream didn't break me out or give me rashes. It can make my face looks oily when applied during the day. Now, I rarely used this because I found another better moisturiser to use daily.

- Give immediate brightening effect in one night.
- Didn't break me out
- Has potent antioxidant

- Too oily to use during the day
- Sting during the first use

Rating: 3.5/5

Hada Labo Hydrating Lotion Milk

Hada Labo Hydrating Lotion Milk

HL hydrating milk contain a lots of humectant and emollient such as 3 types of hyaluronic acid, glycerin, caprylic triglyceride, dimethicone etc. Trial version of this product is fairly enough to use for oily or combination skin.

My verdict: I love using this during the day. This is emulsion or traditional lotion type of moisturiser. This HL milk can retain moisture and hydration throughtout the day. I tried to use it at night but it seems not working. I tried to layer with HL ACE cream, but I got whitehead on the next day. Maybe I can't use the two same function product at a time. Well, to be noted this milk do not have any antioxidants, so it's a bit boring. Anyway, this is decent light moisturiser to use in morning routine or before reapplying sunscreen (for the trial size).

- Give enough moisture
- Retain moisture during the day
- Have decent amount of product in trial packaging

- Don't have antioxidants

Rating: 3/5

Ginvera Marvel White Facial Lotion

Ginvera Marvel White Facial Lotion ingredient list

The highlighted ingredients are green tea as an antioxidant, graden cress and soybean extract as whitening and moisturising agent and shiso extract as anti-flammaotry, soothing ingredient. Also notable ingredients like titanium dioxide (UV filter), aloe vera and licorice extract are found in this product. The texture is just like a normal traditional lotion or emulsion. Some oily skin people like this product but some of them also hate this. It has light green tea smell. I am person who really hate strong smell but this is nice.

My verdict: I want to use this because HL milk does not contain antioxidants. Ginvera lotion is not hydrating enough like HL milk but still good to use during daytime. If I mess up during the cleansing or toning step, this lotion will turn my face to oil slick. For me, it is not doing that much but still okay of you need cheaper alternative for day moisturiser.

- Nice pump packaging
- Lots of beneficial ingredients
- Moisturises good enough
- Affordable

- Not doing that much
- Can be too oily if using too much or wrong skin prep

Rating: 3/5

Cerave Moisturising Cream

Cerave Moisturising Cream ingredient list

Cerave using MVE delivery technology which means the product release active ingredients to penetrate deep into the skin from time to time, so, our skin can avoid dryness.'s too good to be true. However, they have good highlighted ingredient like ceramides and hyaluronic acid that are beneficial for skin's moisture barrier. Cerave cream has normal texture cream just like another moisturising cream in the market. Don't have any scent.

My verdict: This cream is lighter than cetaphil cream I used before (and I hate it). I used this if I am doing exfoliating step or during cold and dry weather or my skin is really dry. I'm glad I did not experienced any stinging or uncomfortable feeling during use. But, my face get oilier in high humidity area after I applied this cream. Final word, this is affordable cream that works really well in whatever drying condition.

- Good for moisture barrier
- Not heavy
- Affordable

- Hard to get in my country
- Not for high humidity condition

Rating: 4/5

Cosmoderm Vitamin E 1000 IU Cream

Cosmoderm Vitamin E 1000 IU Cream ingredient list
Cosmoderm vitamin e cream is a famous product from Cosmoderm. They have two types of vitamin e cream: 1000 iu for normal to oily skin and 3000 iu for dry skin. They also have vitamin e oil product that contain 10000 or 30000 iu I think. Some people rave about this cream for effectiveness in lightening scar. Vitamin e is an antioxidant that also contributing to lightening the scar. The scent is quite strong but not annoying.

My Verdict: Cosmoderm vitamin E cream is not effective on me but the opposite, it gave me whiteheads. I tried to stop and restart all over and still, it is not working. Maybe the oil content is quite high for my skin to tolerate since my skin is not a good friend with olive oil. People ask me to use is for a longer period to see significant effect. But...I can't accept this cream, it is uncomfortable for my liking.

- Affordable
- Contain Vitamin E

- Give me whiteheads
- Feeling uncomfortable

Rating: 1/5

Imju Naturie Hatomugi Conditioning Gel

Imju Naturie Hatomugi Skin Conditioning Gel claims and ingredient list

This is the newest moisturiser I have. Naturie hatomugi gel contain vitamin c form (ascorbyl tetraisopalmitate), a form of vitamin e (sodium tocoperyl phosphate) and Job's tears as moisturising agent. I bought this gel because of the highlighted ingredients. The form of vitamin c and e in this product are fairly new in cosmetic industry. Don't have any scent. The texture it's like almost non-transparent gel.

The price is mindblown for a big tub. This gel is only RM39 (~$9.3) for a normal price, I get discount price for RM35.90 (~$8.6). I've heard that this product have promotion about RM27 (~$6.4). But big tub not always good. 

My verdict: I used this about more than a month and I really love this hatomugi gel. This has been my staple moisturiser currently. That's why I ignoring another moisturisers because this gel is working really well with my skin. I can say it gave you 'wet&bright' effect. Also good for reducing my redness. Currently I have combination skin, this gel balancing oil-water content in my skin really well. This might heavy for oily skin and too light for dry skin. Oily skin may want to use a decent amount, and dry skin might want to layer another moisturising product. I want to give full rating for this but I just use this about a month and come in a big tub. I always have to transfer a good amount to a small jar.

- Cheap
- Effective
- Lightweight
- Reducing redness

-Big tub

Rating: 4/5

All the moisturisers are tested on my combination (dry in u-zone, normal to oily on t-zone and nose area), dehydrated skin. What is effective for me may not effective for you and vice versa.


Thursday, June 15, 2017

Quick and Short about Moisturiser

Assalamualaikum and hi,
What is the properties of a moisturiser and how does moisturiser form? Maybe you can get a little idea to get a suitable moisturiser for your skin. Even me still trying and testing a few moisturisers.

Properties of Moisturiser
  1. Humectant  - works by attracting humidity from surrounding. Effective with lower percentage. Berkesan pada lower percentage. Example: glycerin, butleyne glycol, hyaluronic acid, lactic acid, urea, sodium hyaluronate, honey etc
  2. Emollient - smooths and soften the skin surface. Filling the spaces in the surface skin and binding the skin cells back. Example: fatty acids, ceramides, squalene, jojoba oil, any light oils
  3. Occlusive - trap all the moisture (humectant and emollient). This is what makes your skin look greasy. Example: Mineral oil, petrolatum, beeswax, lanolin, olive oil, shea butter.

Choosing a suitable moisturiser
  • Dry skin - Use moisturiser that rich with emollients and occlusive to keep your skin well-hydrated and moisturised. 
  • Oily skin - Good humectant and emollient helps control the oil production. Too much occlusive makes oily skin suffocated.
  • Follow skintype is not enough. Surrounding, weather and humidity also play important role. Me as people who live in a tropical country, need humectant and some emollient based moisturiser. If you stay in the air conditioner room for a long time, you need an occlusive. AC will dry your skin out.
  • Or you just apply any type of moisturiser according to what your skin behave that day.
  • For acne prone skin, you can choose moisturiser full with ceramides, oil-free, non comodegenic, no mineral oil. You can read here for further info. 

How to layering?
After washing, first apply humectant (hydrating toner, essence, serum) onto the skin, then the emollient rich product (serum, ampoule, emulsion, milk), finally you can apply occlusive based moisturiser to seal all the moisture. You have to consider from thinner to thickest. More thicker moisturiser you have, more occlusive they have. You need to avoid apply occlusives directly onto the skin, it will make your skin more dehydrated. Labmuffin has explained so well here.

I will share review on moisturiser I am currently using.
That's all. Bye, wassalam.

Saturday, June 10, 2017

Battle of Sunscreens: Skin&Lab vs Kiss Me Sunkiller vs A'pieu

Assalamualaikum and Hi!

If you want to know my previous sunscreen history, you can read here. Moreover, it's really difficult to find sunscreen that suit your skin. Especially when majority of sunscreens formula always reformulate and discontinue. I tried and tested for all these 3 sunscreens about almost a year.

Move on to the reviews:

Skin&Lab Fre-C Sun Protector SPF50+ PA+++
Price: RM50 ~ $11
Weight: 50g

Ingredients: water, cyclopentasiloxane, ethylhexyl methoxycinnamate, glycerin, ethylhexyl salicylate, zinc oxide, peg-10 dimethicone, titanium dioxide, dimethicone, niacinamide, dipropylene glycol, tocopheryl acetate, ascorbic acid, astrocaryum murumuru seed butter, magnesium sulfate, disteardimonium hectorite, c30-45 alkyl cetearyl dimethicone crosspolymer, vinyl dimethicone/ methicone silsesquioxane crosspolymer, cetyl peg/ ppg 10/ 1 dimethicone, isoamyl p-methoxycinnamate, aluminium hydroxide, stearic acid, glyceryl caprylate, caprylyl glycol, talc, phenoxyethanol, fragrance, iron oxides.

UV filters used:
1. Octinoxate - UVB and certain UVA
2. Octisalate - UVB
3. Zinc Oxide - UVB and UVA
4. Titanium Dioxide - UVB and certain UVA
5. Amiloxate - Just stated it's only light absorber, no further information.

As you can see from the ingredients, there are a lots of beneficial ingredients such as niacinimide, vitamin e and vitamin c.

The product comes out as almost yellow-orange color and thick texture. When blending out with my skin, it leaves a little whitecast.
My verdict: I like this sunscreen the most between the 3 because it has zinc oxide. I can't ask for more for this sunscreen, it has all the properties I need. Antioxidants, physical blocker and light whitecast. My face easily red, a little whitecast really helpful in cancelling them out. A bit greasy if I stay under the sun for too long. Just have a mild citrus scent. Final word, this sunscreen is really effective.

Kiss Me Sunkiller Perfect Water Essence SPF50+ PA++++

Price: RM30 ~ $7
Size: 50g

Ingredients: water, ethylhexyl methoxycinnamate, diethylamino hydrobenzyl benzoate, pentylene glycol, sodium acetylated hyaluronate, sodium hyaluronate, hydrolyzed hyaluronic acid, saxifraga sermentosa extract, aloe barbadensis leaf extract, royal jelly extract, isononyl isononoate, bis-ethylhexyloxyphenol methoxyphenyl triazine, sodium acrylate / sodium acryloyldimethyl taurate copolymer, titanium dioxide, isohexadecane, aluminum starch octenylsuccinate, ethylhexylglycerin, polysorbate 80, sodium dilauramidoglutamide lysine, aluminum hydroxide, stearic acid, xantha gum, sorbitan oleate, phenoxyethanol, fragrance, ammonium acryloyldimethyltaurate / VP copolymer, tocopherol, BHT, t-butyl alcohol.

UV filters used:
1. Octinoxate - UVB and certain UVA
2. Uvinul A plus - certain UVA
3. Tinosrb S - UVB and UVA
4. Titanium Dioxide - UVB and certain UVA

According to the ingredients, this sunscreen has a lots of moisturising ingredients: 3 types of hyaluronic acid and royal jelly; and antioxidant which is strawberry begonia extract. This chemical sunscreen might not going well for oily and sensitive skin.

The product is really lightweight and the texture is almost gel-like. It has not whitecast but it will brighten up your skin temporarily. Plus, it makes your skin looks glowing and moisturising. I think most people with normal skin can skip moisturiser while using this.

My verdict: This sunscreen broke me out at first. It really makes my face looking like an oil slick if I did not wait until it dry before going out or I really stay under the sun for too long. However, it is good if I stay in air-conditioning room or during cold climate. This sunscreen won't drying out my skin. Somehow, I managed to used this sunscreen outside with condition I must put powder on top. Has natural citrus scent.

A'pieu Natural Sun Cream SPF45 PA+++
Price: RM25~ $5.9
Size: 50ml

Ingredients: Water, Ethylhexyl Methoxycinnamate, Ethylhexyl Salicylate, Butylene Glycol, Phenylbenzimidazole Sulfonic Acid, Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, Butyl Methoxydibenzoylmethane, Bis-ethylhexyloxyphenol Methoxyphenyl Triazine, Methyl Methacrylate Crosspolymer, Glyceryl Stearate, Cirtus Aurantifolia, Cetearyl Olivate, Adansonia Digitata Seed Extract, Prunus Persica Flower Extract, Cetearyl Alcohol, Nylon-12, Sorbitan Olivate, Sodium Hydroxide, Pyrus Malus, Dimethicone, Polyacrylate-13, Panthenol, Polyisobutene, PEG-100 Stearate, Tocopheryl Acetate, Punica Granatum Flower Extract, Sorbitan Stearate, Oryza Sativa, Malpighia Emarginata, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract, Eucalyptus Globulus Leaf Extract, Rosa Centifolia Flower Water, Prunus Avium, Citurs Aurantium Dulcis, Citrullus Lanatus Fruit Extract, Sorbitan Isostearate, Polysorbate 20, BHT, Disodium EDTA, 1,2-Hexanediol, Ethylhexylglycerin, Caprylyl Glycol, Flavor/Fragrance.

UV filters:
1. Octinoxate: UVB and certain UVA
2. Octisalate: UVB
3. Ensulizale: UVB
4. Avobenzone: certain UVB and UVA
5. Tinosorb S: UVA and UVB

This full chemical sunscreen has good formulation though. It has a few antioxidants: Lime extract, apple extract; moisturising agent: peach. People getting confused over avobenzone and oxybenzone. The problematic ingredient is oxybenzone.

The consistency is really light. It has white color. It will leave your skin semi matte finish. 

My verdict: The feeling is the same as Sunkiller Perfect Water Essence except this sunscreen did not break me out. It become greasy when stay under the sun for too long or did not wait for 20-30 minutes before going out. Put the powder on top can save all the problems. At least, it less greasier than Sunkiller Perfect Water Essence. The scent is the same as Neutrogena Dry Touch Sunblock I used before. Both has avobenzone. I don't know if the smell due to avobenzone? The smell is citrusy-like and a bit strong.

Results: Skin&Lab Fre-C Sun Protector > A'pieu Natural Sun Cream Daily => Sunkiller Perfect Water Essence

The similarity between all these 3 sunscreens are the size. Of course, I choose Skin&Lab Sun Protector because it contains zinc oxide and thicker texture which I don't need to use much and last longer. I don't follow the rule 1/4teaspoon or 2mg/cm2 as long I apply powder on top and reapply during lunch hour. It makes my skin suffocated whenever I follow the rule. It has high spf and high UVA rating, so no worries.

Okay, that's it. See you next post.
Bye, wassalam.

UPDATED 14/7/2017 : Something happen! Skin&Lab Sun Protection suddenly did not work out for me. It sting, greasy, i just can't put it on my face. Leave my face red after I remove with micellar water. I want to cry because I love how this sunscreen contain zinc oxide+antioxidants. However, Sunkiller Perfect water essence is working really great, I have no problem with layering two times. Of course I have to put powder on top.

Tuesday, May 23, 2017

Battle of Hada Labo Face Wash: Gokujyun vs Shirojyun vs Tamagohada AHA+BHA

Assalamuaikum and hi!

I am back again from a long hiatus. This is the second post for 2017 but it almost mid-year. In this entry, I want to put my face washes on battle. They all from Hada Labo (HL) again. I know it's boring, but it works for me.

When it come to face wash, I don't expect anything except washing my face from any dirt and excessive oils without feeling tight and dry. Face wash is not going to heal your acne, diminish your blackheads, brightening your skin up. It just CLEANSE! Face wash is just face wash.

Let's get into details of the cleansers.

From left: HL Gokujyun Face Wash, HL Tamagohada AHA+BHA Face Wash, HL Shirojyun Face Wash

Hada Labo Gokujyun (Moisturising) Face Wash

Ingredients: Water, Butylene Glycol, Sodium Myristoyl Glutamate, Sorbitol, Sodium Methyl Cocoyl Taurate, Sodium Lauroyl Glutamate, Cocomide DEA, Myristic Acid, Lauric Acid, Glyceryl Stearate / PEG-100 Stearate, Sodium Chloride, PEG-40 Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Polyglyceryl-2 Isostearate, Polyquaternium-7, Methyparaben, Hydroxypropyltrimonium Hyaluronate, Sodium Acetylated Hyaluronate

Well, it sulfates-free. They are using mild surfactants and contain two types of hyaluronic acid (HA). Based on ingredients it looks mild. It has pH 5 closely to our skin pH. Claims to be hydrating and refresh.

My verdict: This is quite hydrating. But still leave my skin feeling tight and dry. The foam is not dense when lathering with foaming net. I prefer lots of foam to avoid strong pressure. Putting moisturiser after cleanse with this face wash is a must. Don't have any scent.

Hada Labo Shirojyun (Whitening) Face Wash
Ingredients: Water, Butylene Glycol, Sodium Myristoyl Glutamate, Sorbitol, Sodium Methyl Cocoyl Taurate, Sodium Lauroyl Glutamate, Cocomide DEA, Lauric Acid, Myristic Acid, Glyceryl Stearate / PEG-100 Stearate, Sodium Chloride, PEG-40 Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Citrus Paradisi (Grapefruit) Peel Oil, Citrus Aurentium Dulcis (Orange) Peel Oil, Arbutin, Glycerin / Arbutin / Angelica Polymorpha Sinensis Root Extract / Morus Alba Bark Extract / Syringa Oblata Bark / Leaf Powder / Paeonia Albiflora Root Extract / Perilla Frutescens Extract / Bletilla Striata Root Extract / Ampelopsis Japonica Extract / Poria Cocos Extract / Atractyloides Macrocephala Root Extract, Sodium Acetylated Hyaluronate

The ingredients are still the same as Gokujyun but with additional of arbutin, citrus oils and plant extracts. They claimed this face wash can brightening our complexion and hydrating. I found that this face wash has pH 4. I don't really expect the pH was that low, but with all the citrus and plant extract, it might be reasonable.

My verdict: This is more hydrating than Gokujyun face wash. The foam is not dense. It has mild citrus scent, people who don't have sensitive nose will not notice the smell. It does not brightening up my skin but who need that. The downside, this can be too mild so, it is not cleanse well for oilier skin. The best out of the three. Near to be my holy grail, I repurchasing it many times.

Hada Labo Tamagohada AHA+BHA Face Wash
Ingredients: Water, Butylene Glycol, Potassium Myristoyl Glutamate, PEG-450, Lauramidopropyl Betaine, Stearic Acid, Lauramide DEA, Glycolic Acid, Lauric Acid, Cocamidopropyl Hydroxysultaine, Glycol Distearate, Potassium Hydroxide, Methylparaben, Saliylic Acid, Sodium PCA / Betaine / Sorbitol / Glycine / Alanine / Proline / Serine / Threonine / Arginine / Lysine / Glutamic Acid / Methylparaben / Propylparaben / Water

This is also known as gentle exfoliating wash. Did they put word 'exfoliating' just because this cleanser has exfoliating properties? Of course glycolic acid and salicylic acid are not working because it will wash away. They claimed this face wash will deep cleanse into pores, diminish blackheads and dullness. It known to have pH 6.

My verdict: Nowadays, I don't do scrubbing or peeling gels, so I just depend on this so called exfoliating face wash. When I was first time using this, I used every night until my face getting really dry and tight, so, I change to 2-3 times a week. It works for deep cleansing in a milder way. I can't think of any exfoliating product to have except this one. I admit there alots of face wash that can do deep cleansing better, especially with clay ingredient. Since I can't really use clay, this face wash is the best option.

People who are really into skincare understand that we should use low pH cleanser. But I am so lazy and cheapskate to spend money on pH strip. Therefore, I just depend on r/Ab community to check my cleanser's pH even though the accuracy is questionable. For me, the ideal cleanser's pH is from 4-7. Is pH matter or not, it depends on your preference. In my point of view, the important part is the comfortability during and after washing follow by applying moisturiser afterwards. There are high pH cleanser that make our skin feeling comfortable and low pH cleanser that makes our skin feeling tight. Skincare is supposed to be comfortable and relaxing.

RESULT: HL Shirojyun Face Wash > HL Tamoagohada AHA+BHA Face Wash > HL Gokujyun Face Wash

Okay, that's all. See again for the next post. Bye, wassalam.

Tuesday, February 28, 2017

Battle Of Hada Labo Lotions: Shirojyun vs Gokujyun Vs Mild Peeling

Assalamualaikum & Hi!

For this post I would like to write about Hada Labo lotions. My skincare routine consists Hada Labo products mostly. Why I chose Hada Labo? There are a lots of skincare product that have better ingredients and affordable. These are my reasons:
  • They are no fragrance and mineral oil. Most of the products contain no alcohol
  • They are easily access. I am too lazy to do research for other skincare
  • Found a lots of reviews from worldwide
  • Provide detail information about R&D and ingredients of the products
  • Mostly are pH balance and gentle for my skin
  • From a big pharmaceutical company Rohto-Mentholatum
  • They don't claim the products are all rounded. They are mainly focus on hydration.
  • Of course I've been influenced by the advertisement. Jun ji hyun is so pretty.
Too much points to put. But not all HL products suit me as I already mentioned on a post before. Back to the title, what exactly they means lotion? For us lotion is light moisturiser. But in Japanese, lotion has toner consistency. Japanese lotion is used to prepare skin for the next skincare steps. Ratzilla has wrote in simple explanation about Japanese lotion. HL lotions are a bit different from another Japanese lotions because there are no trace of alcohol (which is my enemy). I tried to take a look on cheaper options like Senka, Sana, Juju Aquamoist but most of them contain alcohol. I don't want to risk my skin testing them. It takes time and money to heal. So, the safest thing to do is I should stick with HL lotions until it has no effects. Let's move on to the comparison:

Hada Labo Gokujyun Lotion (2016 formulation), Hada Labo Mild Peeling Lotion, Hada Labo Shirojyun Lotion (2013 formulation)

Hada Labo Shirojyun (Arbutin/Whitening) Lotion
Ingredients: Water, Dipropylene Glycol, Glycerin, Arbutin, Betine, PPG-10 Methyl Glucose Esther, Styrene/VP Copolymer, Disodium Succinate, Methylparaben, Tremella Fuciformes Polysaccharide, Succinic Acid, Sodium Hyaluronate, Magnesium Ascorbyl Phosphate

Take note this is the old formula. There a lots of different formula I found by another beauty bloggers, different manufacturer and batch. Arbutin is quite high in the list. Arbutin can be obtained synthetically or from bearberry extract. Arbutin is known as skin lightening agent. I bought this from early 2014 where the rich version was not ready yet. Plus, contain stable Vitamin C, Magnesium Ascorbyl Phosphate (MAP), the very least amount out of all ingredients. I bought this because I am too scared to used Gokujyun since I have oily skin back then. I don't mind about whitening effect, I just want a light product.

My verdict: Shirojyun lotion gives good hydration. Not as much as Gokujyun but still decent. I didn't see this lotion brighten up my skin, at least it makes my skin less dull. Thank goodness this arbutin lotion did not irritate my skin. Since I've read that arbutin inhibit the melanin formation, I feel a bit worried for a long term effect. I have finished one bottle. Final words, this lotion is a good hydrating toner.

Hada Labo Gokujyun (Moisturising) Lotion
Ingredients: Water, Butelyne Glycol, Glycerin, PPG-10 Methyl Glucose Esther, Disodium Succinate, Methylparaben, Sodium Hyaluronate (Medium Size HA), Hydroxyethylcellulose, Succinic Acid, Sodium Hyaluronate (Large Size HA), Hyaluronic Acid (Nano HA), Sodium Acetylated Hyaluronate (Super HA).

Again, of course the formulation is different according to manufacturer and batch. Mine is 2016 formulation and manufactured in China. Don't be shook when you heard it is made in China, it is designed for South East Asian country (humid weather country). I heard that Indonesia has their own manufacturer.
According to Hada Labo Malaysia website, HL Gokujyun lotion has 4 different kinds of hyaluronic acid. Medium, Large, Nano and Super HA (what?!). Nano HA penetrate into the skin, medium and super HA are on the skin surface, lastly the large HA protect the skin from water loss. But...HA is humectant, I don't think it works as moisture sealer like occlusive does.

My verdict: I love HL Gokujyun lotion so much. It changed my skin from very oily to normal-combination. My skin getting oilier or drier if I don't put this lotion on. I put this lotion after prayer, before reapply my sunscreen/sunblock. This lotion is must have and never skip item in my routine.

Hada Labo Mild Peeling Lotion
Ingredients: Water, Gluconic Acid, Pentylene Glycol, Butelyne Glycol, Tranexamic Acid, Polyquartenium-51, Sodium Metabisulfite

Finally, the lotion you can swipe with cotton pad. This lotion is another level from the previous two. This is exfoliating toner because it contains Gluconic Acid, an exfoliating property. I don't know if I can classify gluconic acid as PHA (polyhydroxy acid). Notable PHA ingredient is Glunolactone, they are related since I have limited knowledge in chemistry, I cannot conclude anything. PHA is working like AHA (alpha hydroxy acid) but milder and less sensitizing. Tranexamic acid is brightening ingredient, this studies show how 3% trenaxamic acid works on treating melasma patient without side effects in comparison with hydroquinone.

My verdict: HL mild peeling lotion is a game changer. I use this like traditional toner, put a few drops on cotton pad and swipe my face, I use it 2 times a day after cleansing. I should thanks to femaledaily and Afifi Assegaf, they provide good information, technique and reviews for this lotion. Even though this lotion are not readily available in their country. I'm on my 2nd bottle now. 
Below photos show how HL mild peeling lotion really change my skin, most whiteheads are disappeared especially on forehead. I always do get big pimple on forehead, but after I introduced this mild peeling lotion, I did not get any pimple on my forehead except a few whiteheads (verrrry rare).

I started using HL mild peeling lotion on July 2016. I did not put any makeup on, just a chemical, non whitecast sunscreen.
Again, no makeup at all, I still have scars. With artificial lighting.

Recent photo. I do still get pimples. I have slightly whitecast sunscreen on. With natural lighting.
I am not using HL mild peeling lotion alone to get rid the bumps, acnes, whiteheads and blackheads. It works by allowing penetration of another products easily. Double cleanse, moisturise and use physical sunscreen is the key to improve my skin condition. I still have problems like redness, scars, dry patches and sensitivity. Alhamdulillah my skin is getting better and I am also getting fatter.

RESULT : HL Gokujyun Lotion = HL Mild Peeling Lotion >= HL Shirojyun Lotion

Take note: Both Shirojyun and Gokujyun lotions have more humectant properties. I am advising don't use these lotions alone when you spent a lots of time in dry surrounding like air conditioning office, cold climate country, winter. Humectant works by attracting humidity from the surrounding. Better use hydrating lotion plus light moisturiser when you are in dry surrounding or winter. Yay for people who always stay in humidity area.

I hope I am giving you lots of idea to find a suitable products. Introduce all products one by one so you know which is working for you. Do a lots of research, only YOU know your own skin. If you have doubts, you can refer the dermatologist.

Bye, wassalam.

Follow my blog with Bloglovin